Review & #Giveaway – Picture Not Perfect by D.E. Haggerty @dehaggerty #cozy #mystery
Picture Not Perfect (The Not So Reluctant Detectives)
Cozy Mystery/Romance/Humor
2nd in Series
Self Published (January 21, 2019)
Print Length: 230 pages
A picture tells a story. But is it the truth?
When the police find pictures of Melanie hanging up at her murdered colleague’s house, they’re convinced he was stalking her. Maybe she even killed him. Melanie was not being stalked! And she certainly didn’t kill her supposed stalker – as if. But Mel – always up for a bit of drama – jumps at the chance to go search for the real killer. When Mel’s ex-boyfriend, Owen, discovers her plans, he pulls out all the stops to ensure she’s safe and to win her back. No matter what happens with the murder investigation, he’s not letting her go. With the police setting their sights on Mel, he may need to jeopardize his own career on the police force to protect her.
Will Mel find the real killer before the detectives arrest her for murder?
Review
I had a love-hate relationship with this book.
On one hand, I loved the book and the mystery portion because I did not suspect the killer until the clues were all revealed at the end and it was quite a surprise how it all came together. I also loved the addition of Pru, the English Lit teacher that somehow found herself dragged into the middle of Melanie and Terri’s shenanigans. I even loved how we learned more about Melanie and Owen’s relationship and what went wrong or why Melanie broke it off with Owen.
On the other hand, I did not like Melanie at all, or very little. She was like the Energizer Bunny on speed and while we learn why she is this way, I felt like it was over the top and no sane person would jump to as many conclusions as she did throughout the book. While I know she is a suspect in her fellow teacher’s murder and wants to clear her name, it was just too much for me.
I should note that the first book had Terri as the protagonist and I enjoyed that book. Probably because Terri is calmer. There will be a third book that features Pru and based on what we know about her character I think it will be more like the first book.
Overall I did enjoy the book and do recommend it, just be warned that Melanie will be all over the highway with her theories and suspicions.
We give this 4 paws up
About the Author
I grew up reading everything I could get my grubby hands on, from my mom’s Harlequin romances to Nancy Drew, to Little Women. When I wasn’t flipping pages in a library book, I was penning horrendous poems, writing songs no one should ever sing, or drafting stories which have thankfully been destroyed. College and a stint in the U.S. Army came along, robbing me of free time to write and read, although on the odd occasion I did manage to sneak a book into my rucksack between rolled up socks, MRIs, t-shirts, and cold weather gear. After surviving the army experience, I went back to school and got my law degree. I jumped ship and joined the hubby in the Netherlands before the graduation ceremony could even begin. A few years into my legal career, I was exhausted, fed up, and just plain done. I quit my job and sat down to write a manuscript, which I promptly hid in the attic after returning to the law. But practicing law really wasn’t my thing, so I quit (again!) and went off to Germany to start a B&B. Turns out running a B&B wasn’t my thing either. I polished off that manuscript languishing in the attic before following the husband to Istanbul where I decided to give the whole writer-thing a go. But ten years was too many to stay away from my adopted home. I packed up again and moved to The Hague where I’m currently working on my next book. I hope I’ll always be working on my next book.
Kay Garrett
Thank you for your review on “Picture Not Perfect” by D.E. Haggerty and for being part of the book tour.
I’d love the opportunity to read this amazing sounding book which is now on my TBR list.
StoreyBook Reviews
It was still a GREAT book! Did not suspect the killer at all
D.E. Haggerty
Thank you for your honest review. I realize Melanie is a difficult character. I knew readers would have a tough time with her, but she was oh so much fun to write. Pru is a much more palatable character. I actually think she may turn out to be the toughest of the bunch.
Thanks again for taking the time to read and review Picture Not Perfect.