Heads You Lose – Lisa Lutz & David Hayward

StoreyBook Reviews 

Heads You Lose is a joint collaboration between Lisa Lutz (known for The Spellman Files series) and David Hayward (He writes poetry and has a editing/writing company).  The authors each write a chapter and then hand it off to the other.  In between the chapters there are comments about what is written and David’s foray into some alternate reality where there are strange reality shows. 

This is the official book overview from the website:

From New York Times–bestselling author Lisa Lutz and David Hayward comes a hilarious and original tag-team novel that reads like Weeds meets Adaptation.

Meet Paul and Lacey Hansen: orphaned, pot-growing, twentysomething siblings eking out a living in rural Northern California. When a headless corpse appears on their property, they can’t exactly dial 911, so they move the body and wait for the police to find it. Instead, the corpse reappears, a few days riper … and an amateur sleuth is born. Make that two.

But that’s only half of the story. When collaborators Lutz and Hayward—former romantic partners—start to disagree about how the story should unfold, the body count rises, victims and suspects alike develop surprising characteristics (meet Brandy Chester, the stripper with the Mensa IQ), and sibling rivalry reaches homicidal intensity. Will the authors solve the mystery without killing each other first?

My Thoughts:

I was given this book to read from a friend in my book club a few months ago but just picked it up this week.  I had been told that the authors alternate writing each chapter but she didn’t tell me that there were comments in between each chapter and footnotes!  I have laughed my way through the whole book while trying to figure out who is committing the crimes.  I especially loved chapter 14.  I’m not going to say why, that would spoil the fun.  But if you pick up this book to read, don’t jump to that chapter, you won’t understand the humor.

I definitely recommend this book if you want a little mystery but a lot of humor too.  It is definitely light hearted and the interaction between the two authors between each chapter also gives you some good insight into why they wrote what they wrote, well sometimes.

Recommended Posts

excerpt Short Story

Excerpt – Dave and the Treehouse by Jim Bates

  Synopsis A flustered waitress is given a magic wand she uses to teach a bully a lesson. A young girl is befriended by a kindly oak tree and together they dispose of her abusive father. An oceanographer’s life is changed when he meets and befriends a merman. An abusive folksinger messes with the wrong […]

StoreyBook Reviews 
5 paws Fantasy Giveaway Review romance Romantic Comedy Texas

Review & Giveaway – The New Year’s Man by Michael Scott Clifton

  THE NEW YEAR’S MAN By Michael Scott Clifton   Romantic Fantasy / Romantic Comedy Publication Date: September 11, 2026   Synopsis Landry LeBlanc has everything he wants: a luxury condo, a fast-rising legal career, expensive taste, and an ironclad rule against falling in love. Relationships, to him, come with expiration dates—and New Year’s Eve […]

StoreyBook Reviews 
Cozy Giveaway Guest Post mystery

Guest Post & Giveaway – Up the Creek by Shelly Marsh

    Up the Creek: A Florida Eco-Mystery Mystery Stand Alone Setting – Florida Publisher ‏ : ‎ Sibylline Digital First Publication date ‏ : ‎ October 2, 2026 Print length ‏ : ‎ 300 pages Synopsis In the Florida marshlands, Amanda finds herself in a fight that’s personal, political, and deadly After losing her […]

StoreyBook Reviews