Guest Post & Giveaway – Murder in the Winner’s Circle by M.J. Evans


Murder In The Winner’s Circle: A Harness Racing Mystery
Cozy Mystery
2nd in Series
Setting – Pennsylvania
Publisher : Dancing Horse Press
Print Length – 257 Pages
Synopsis
A Birthday Celebration. A Champion Horse. A Deadly Toast.
Alfred Wellington has everything he wants on his sixtieth birthday. His prized colt just won at Liberty Racetrack, the champagne is flowing, and the crowd is cheering.
Then Alfred collapses.
At first, everyone assumes it was a heart attack—until the autopsy reveals the truth.
ALFRED WELLINGTON WAS POISONED.
Former insurance investigator Callie Oaks Coffman knows Liberty Racetrack inside and out. She knows its horses, its owners, its trainers—and she knows that secrets can get someone killed. As she and her new husband, reporter Paul Coffman, become drawn into the investigation, Callie discovers that Alfred left behind plenty of people with reasons to want him dead.
A beautiful young wife.
A secretive trainer.
A bitter ex-wife.
A business partner with something to hide.But which one of them is the killer?
BECAUSE IN THE WINNER’S CIRCLE, EVERYONE HAS SOMETHING TO HIDE.
Return to the world of Liberty Racetrack in the second Harness Racing Mystery, following Fire at the Track.
Amazon * B&N
Read for Free via Kindle+
Guest Post
Red Herrings and Racing Secrets: How I Keep Readers Guessing Until the End
By M.J. Evans, award-winning author of the Harness Racing Mystery Series
I love a good mystery. Give me a cast of intriguing characters, a handful of suspicious circumstances, and clues that don’t quite add up, and I’m happy to spend hours trying to figure out whodunit.
As a mystery writer, though, I have a different challenge: How do I keep readers guessing when I already know the answer?
The secret is not simply to hide the clues. It’s to give readers enough information to solve the mystery while making several possible explanations seem convincing. I want readers to suspect one character, change their minds two chapters later, and then wonder whether they’ve overlooked something important.
In my Harness Racing Mystery Series, the world of harness racing provides the perfect place to play this game.
Everyone Needs a Motive
When I develop a mystery, I begin by thinking about the people involved. Who are they? What do they want? What are they afraid of losing? And what secrets might they be desperate to protect?
In Murder in the Winner’s Circle, prominent harness racing owner Alfred Wellington collapses during his sixtieth-birthday celebration after his colt wins a race. What begins as a celebration quickly becomes a murder investigation when the evidence reveals that Alfred was poisoned.
Alfred’s death sends investigators into the complicated lives of the people around him. His wife, business associates, and those connected with his horses all have their own relationships with him—and their own reasons for not wanting certain details exposed.
A character doesn’t have to be a murderer to behave suspiciously. Someone may be concealing an affair, a financial problem, a professional mistake, or an embarrassing secret. That person may lie to protect a reputation rather than to cover up a killing.
But how is the detective—or the reader—supposed to know the difference?
That’s where the fun begins!
The Art of the Red Herring
A red herring is a clue or circumstance that leads readers toward the wrong conclusion. Used well, it creates uncertainty without making the mystery feel unfair.
I don’t want to trick readers by withholding information they should reasonably have. Instead, I want to present facts that can be interpreted in more than one way.
A character’s unusual behavior might look like evidence of guilt. Later, readers may discover another explanation. A seemingly insignificant conversation might take on a new meaning when viewed alongside a clue that appears much later.
The important thing is that the details make sense when the truth finally comes out. Readers should be able to look back and recognize how the pieces fit together—even if they didn’t assemble them correctly the first time.
I also try to remember that every suspect should feel like a real person. If all the clues point toward someone who has no believable reason to commit the crime, readers will quickly lose confidence in the story. Each suspect needs a history, relationships, and circumstances that make the possibility of guilt worth considering.
Why a Racetrack Is a Mystery Writer’s Playground
Harness racing offers an especially rich environment for a mystery because so many different interests intersect in one place.
Owners invest money and emotion in their horses. Trainers work hard to produce winners. Drivers compete for success. Stable employees see what happens behind the scenes, and business relationships can be just as complicated as personal ones.
A winning horse can bring prestige and financial rewards, while a disappointing result can create frustration and suspicion. Add rivalries, ambition, jealousy, and secrets, and a writer has plenty of possibilities to explore.
In Murder in the Winner’s Circle, the celebration surrounding a successful race becomes the setting for a shocking death. The contrast is part of what makes the situation so compelling: one moment, everyone is celebrating a victory; the next, they are wondering whether someone among them is a killer.
The racetrack’s close-knit community adds another challenge. People may know one another’s habits and histories, but familiarity doesn’t necessarily mean they know the whole truth.
And neither does the reader!
My Amateur Sleuth Has to Earn Her Answers
Callie Oaks Coffman, the sleuth at the center of my series, brings her own experience and instincts to each investigation. She knows the harness racing world and understands that the people involved cannot always be judged by appearances.
But Callie doesn’t simply point at the most suspicious person and declare the case solved. She has to ask questions, consider competing explanations, notice inconsistencies, and work out which details matter.
I want readers to have the opportunity to do the same thing. As Callie learns more, readers should be able to reconsider their own theories. A new piece of information may strengthen one suspicion while undermining another.
Of course, Callie has an advantage: she is inside the story. Readers have to rely on the clues I choose to give them!
Fair Play—and a Few Surprises
For me, the most satisfying mystery is one that surprises readers without disappointing them.
The ending should make sense, even if it wasn’t what they expected. The solution should explain the important clues, resolve the central questions, and reveal why the truth was so difficult to see.
That balance takes planning. I have to keep track of what each character knows, what each person is hiding, and when the reader discovers each piece of information. A clue revealed too early might make the answer obvious. A clue revealed too late might feel as though it came out of nowhere.
I want readers to finish the book thinking, I should have seen that!—and then perhaps turn back a few pages to see exactly where the story gave them the chance.
Can You Solve the Mystery?
In Murder in the Winner’s Circle, Alfred Wellington’s birthday celebration ends in tragedy, and Callie must help untangle the secrets surrounding his death. There are suspects to question, motives to examine, and clues to weigh carefully.
I won’t tell you which details are most important. That would spoil the fun!
Instead, I invite you to pay attention to the people around Alfred, consider what each might have to gain or lose, and question your first impressions. The most obvious suspect may not be the guilty one—and the person who seems to have the least to hide may know more than you think.
After all, in both mystery writing and harness racing, appearances can be deceiving.
May the best detective win!
About the Author
M.J. Evans is the award-winning author of twenty six published works spanning middle-grade, young adult, and adult fiction, as well as a selection of picture books. Her writing often explores themes centered around horses and equine fantasy, reflecting a lifelong passion for these remarkable animals. A graduate of Oregon State University and a former educator with experience teaching both middle and high school students, Ms. Evans brings both educational insight and storytelling flair to her work. She resides in beautiful Colorado with her husband, Tom, where they enjoy the company of their horses and Standard Poodle. She is the proud mother of five and grandmother of thirteen.
M.J. Evans was the recipient of the 2024 Colorado Authors League Lifetime Achievement Award.
Literary awards include: Chanticleer International Book Awards Readers’ Favorite International Awards Eric Hoffer Awards Nautilus Awards Literary Classics awards Literary Global Book Awards Feathered Quill Book Awards Purple Dragonfly Awards Royal Dragonfly Awards Page Turner Award Next Generation Award Global Book Awards CIPA Evvy Book Awards Pinnacle Book Achievement Awards Incipere Book Awards International Impact Book Awards Maincrest Media Book Awards Book Excellence Awards Mom’s Choice Awards